cashbox, money, currency, cash box, finance, money box, euro, cash, cashbox, cash box, cash box, cash box, finance, money box, money box, cash, cash, cash, cash, cash
Photo by Alexas_Fotos on Pixabay

Offer Design

Part of Subscription pricing and contribution margin

Pricing a subscription without relying on permanent introductory discounts

Set a workable continuing subscription price, define any first-box offer clearly and avoid treating an ongoing discount as temporary.

This is an editorial pen name used by the publication, not a claim of an independently verified personal identity. Original editorial credit: Desk Subscription Strategy.

Set a continuing price that works for an ordinary shipment before offering a cheaper first box. State when an introductory price ends and show the later charge before sign-up. If a discount continues indefinitely, assess it as the actual selling price.

The ACCC takes the same view of prices on display: where an item is offered at a sale or special price for an extended period, it may be misleading to call it a sale or special price, because that price has effectively become the new selling price.

Price the continuing box first

Cost the usual contents, packaging, packing, delivery and payment. Decide what contribution the order must leave, then test whether customers value the offer at its delivered price. If the price does not work, reconsider the contents, quantity, frequency or service before assuming a later price rise will fix it.

In a hypothetical example, a lower first-box price reduces the contribution left by that shipment compared with the ordinary price. The calculation should use your own costs, prices and consistent treatment of taxes.

If later boxes also sell at the lower price, their contribution is lower again. Any such calculation illustrates the effect of a price reduction; it is not a suggested price or evidence of demand.

Keep GST on the same footing on both sides of that sum. The price shown to consumers is a different matter: the ACCC says businesses must display the total price as a single figure, the minimum total cost including any taxes, duties and unavoidable or pre-selected extra fees. A consumer box price is therefore shown with GST included.

Put a clear boundary on the offer

Specify which shipment receives the lower price, the reduction, eligibility and the next charge. Cost the first shipment separately if it includes a gift, different packaging or another delivery service. Include those costs in the offer calculation.

Show the amount due now, the ordinary later price and when it first applies. A plain form is: “First box at the introductory price, then the ordinary price per box from your second delivery, charged before each dispatch until you cancel.”

Disclose delivery or other fees from the start. The ACCC warns against drip pricing and says businesses must clearly disclose at the start of a purchasing process the types of fees that will apply and when. Renewal and cancellation wording should match the actual offer.

Keep records that substantiate any price comparisons you make. The ACCC lists as misleading a claim that a price is marked down from an earlier price when the item was not sold at that earlier price for a reasonable period right before the sale started. A “was” claim therefore needs records of boxes actually sold at the earlier price.

Give customers a reason to stay

Describe the continuing value plainly: a useful quantity, dependable timing or a curated selection that meets a stated promise. An added product or upgraded delivery has a cost, so include it in the shipment calculation before using it as an alternative to a price reduction.

If different customers need different quantities or intervals, cost each plan against its own promise. The ordinary-price box must still make sense after the introductory offer ends.

Review the charged price

Record first-box revenue and costs separately from later cycles. Check the price actually charged on each order and the contribution it leaves, including any promotion still applied.

Review feedback on the ordinary-price box and whether its stated contents and timing were delivered. An introductory sign-up alone does not establish acceptance of the later price.

Revise the price, plan or offer wording when those records show a problem. For any change affecting existing customers, identify the first affected charge under their actual terms.

ACCC guidelines on subscription pricing transparency

  • Total price display ruleMust show single figure including GST, duties, and unavoidable fees
  • Misleading 'was' pricingOnly valid if product was sold at that price for a reasonable time prior to sale
  • Drip pricing prohibitedAll fees must be disclosed at start of purchase process

More from Offer Design